Fleece or softshell — the choice is never easy between these two garments, which are equally practical and comfortable. Although they are not worn in the same conditions or situations, it is always tricky to choose one without risking missing out on the advantages offered by the other.
The fleece and its characteristics
Generally lighter than the softshell, the fleece doesn't take up much space in a travel bag. Thanks to its simplicity, it can be worn as an outer layer when there is neither wind nor rain. However, it is also very practical as a mid-layer, especially when it rains and it is worn under a waterproof jacket.
Made from synthetic material, the fleece is available in different weights. Some models are therefore heavier or lighter than others. Along the same lines, some fleeces are thicker and thus provide considerably more warmth. One small drawback: the more warmth it provides, the less breathable it is.
The fleece comes in three different versions:
- The heavyweight fleece, which has a density of 300 g/m² and delivers maximum warmth in winter conditions. Although it acts as an effective barrier against the cold, it does not wick moisture away efficiently enough. Its great thickness is therefore a limitation to the comfort it can provide. This model is not very well suited to physical activities requiring a high degree of mobility.
- The lightweight fleece, with a weight of 100 g/m². It is the most suitable version for wearing under a windproof jacket or under a shell jacket. It doesn't provide a great deal of warmth, but it offers far greater comfort thanks to its low thickness. It is in fact the ideal fleece for intense physical activities in the depths of winter (hiking, skating, etc.)
- The mid-weight fleece, which is more breathable than the heavyweight fleece and warmer than the lightweight fleece. More versatile than the other two, it can be worn as an outer layer when the temperature is slightly mild, just as it can be worn as a mid-layer in freezing conditions.
When should you choose the fleece?
To choose between fleece or softshell, certain criteria are highlighted in terms of practicality, functionality, and comfort. The fleece will be chosen for the following advantages:
- Its versatility (worn as an outer jacket in warm seasons and as a mid-layer in inclement weather)
- Its "cosy" feel
- Its weight and thickness according to the desired level of warmth
The features of the softshell jacket
The softshell jacket stands apart from the fleece thanks to the fabric from which it is made. With its water-repellent texture, it can be worn in rainy conditions without needing to be combined with a waterproof jacket. Far more technical, it provides optimal protection against wind and showers, even in the absence of a third layer.
In addition to its windproof effect, the softshell provides more warmth than the fleece. It is therefore less breathable than the latter. Being thicker by nature, it takes up considerably more space in luggage.
What makes the softshell special?
Many features make the softshell a winner in terms of comfort and practicality:
- The material: the interior is lined with fleece and the exterior is made from water-repellent fabric.
- Versatility: a single jacket to protect against wind, cold, and rain.
- Convenience: practical for skiing, cycling, or trail running in mid-season.
Taking into account the advantages and limitations of each, choosing between fleece or softshell is never straightforward. To avoid making the wrong choice, it is important to consider the following factors:
- The cut: these garments should fit as close to the body as possible to prevent heat from escaping.
- Pockets: the presence of pockets is important for optimising the breathability of the garment and controlling body temperature.
- Drawstrings: these are needed to make it easy to adjust the openings at the waist and wrists.
- A hood: to keep the head at the same temperature as the body.
What to go for? Fleece or softshell?
Ultimately, it all comes down to use when choosing between fleece or softshell. The fleece is the preferred choice for wearing as a base layer or as an outer layer on dry, windless outings. The softshell jacket should be selected for outings in more unsettled weather, where protection against wind and light rain is deemed necessary. Thanks to its water-repellent and windproof fabric, the 3-layer softshell garment outperforms the fleece for protection against the elements, and if you don't have a third layer it will also prove very useful. On the other hand, its greater volume may be a drawback when making your choice. It's up to you to assess, based on the weather forecast and the nature of the terrain you'll be crossing, what you put on your back — fleece or softshell!
