Fleece or softshell, the choice is never easy between these two garments that are both equally practical and comfortable. Although they aren't worn in the same conditions and situations, it's always complicated to choose one without risking missing out on the advantages offered by the other.
Fleece and its characteristics
Typically lighter than a softshell, fleece doesn't take up much space in a travel bag. Due to its simplicity, it can be worn as an outer layer when there's no wind or rain. However, it's also very practical as a mid-layer, especially when it rains and it's worn under a waterproof jacket. Made from synthetic material, fleece is available in different weights. Some models are, therefore, heavier or lighter than others. Along the same lines, there are thicker fleeces that provide much more warmth. The downside: the more warmth it provides, the less it is breathable. Fleece comes in three different versions:- Heavy fleece with a density of 300 g/m² that provides maximum warmth in winter. Although it forms an effective barrier against the cold, it doesn't evacuate perspiration well enough. Its thickness is therefore a limitation to the comfort it can provide. This model isn't well suited to physical activities requiring a lot of mobility.
- Lightweight fleece with a weight of 100 g/m². This is the most suitable version to wear under a windbreaker or jacket. It doesn't provide much warmth, but it offers much more comfort thanks to its low thickness. It's actually the ideal fleece for intense physical activities in the middle of winter (hiking, skating, etc.)
- Mid-weight fleece that is more breathable than heavy fleece and provides more warmth than lightweight fleece. More versatile than the other two, it can be worn as an outer layer when the temperature is slightly mild, just as it's worn as a mid-layer in freezing conditions.
When should you choose fleece?
To choose between fleece and softshell, criteria are highlighted in terms of practicality, functionality, and comfort. Fleece will be chosen for the following advantages:- Its multifunctionality (worn as an outer jacket in warm weather and as a mid-layer in bad weather)
- Its cosy feel
- Its weight and thickness according to the desired warmth
The specifics of the softshell jacket
The softshell jacket stands out from fleece through the fabric it's made from. With a water-repellent texture, it can be worn in rainy weather without needing to be combined with a waterproof jacket. More sophisticated, it ensures optimal protection against wind and showers, even without a third layer. In addition to its windproof effect, softshell provides more warmth than fleece. It is therefore less breathable than the latter. Being thicker by nature, it takes up much more space in luggage.
What makes softshell special?
Numerous elements favour softshell in terms of comfort and practicality:- The material: the inside is lined with fleece and the outside is made of water-repellent fabric.
- Versatility: a single jacket to protect against wind, cold, and rain.
- Convenience: practical for skiing, cycling, or trail running in mid-season.
- The fit: these garments must be as close to the body as possible to prevent heat from escaping.
- Pockets: the presence of pockets is important to optimise the garment's breathability and body temperature control.
- Drawcords: they're needed to facilitate adjustment of openings at the waist and wrists.
- A hood: so the head enjoys the same temperature level as the body.
