Fleece or softshell: choosing between these two equally practical and comfortable garments is never easy. Although designed for different conditions and uses, it can be tricky to pick one without compromising on the benefits of the other.
Fleece and its key features
Generally lighter than a softshell, a fleece takes up little room in a travel bag. Its simple design means it can be worn as an outer layer when there is no wind or rain. It also works well as a mid-layer, especially in the rain under a waterproof jacket.
Made from synthetic fabric, fleece comes in different fabric weights. Some styles are heavier or lighter than others. Thicker fleeces provide more warmth, but there is a trade-off: the warmer the fleece, the less breathable it is.
Fleece comes in three main categories:
- Heavyweight fleece with a density of 300 g/m², providing maximum thermal protection in harsh winter conditions. While it acts as an effective cold barrier, it offers lower breathability during exertion. Its thickness can also restrict freedom of movement, making it less suitable for high-output activities.
- Lightweight fleece with a fabric weight of 100 g / m2 is best worn under a windproof jacket or another jacket. It does not provide much warmth, but its thin fabric makes it more comfortable to wear. It is an ideal fleece for intense winter activities such as hiking and skate skiing.
- The midweight fleece, which is more breathable than a heavy fleece and provides more warmth than a microfleece. More versatile than the other two, it can be worn as an outer layer in mild temperatures or as a mid-layer in freezing conditions.
When should you choose a fleece?
When choosing between a fleece and a softshell, several criteria come into play regarding practicality, functionality, and comfort. A fleece is typically chosen for the following benefits:
- Multi-functionality (worn as an outer jacket in mild conditions and as a mid-layer in severe weather)
- Its cosy, comfortable feel
- Weight and thickness according to desired warmth
Key features of a softshell jacket
A softshell jacket differs from a fleece in its fabric. Its water-repellent material means it can be worn in the rain without a waterproof jacket over it. Its more technical construction provides protection against wind and showers, even without a separate outer layer.
In addition to its windproof properties, a softshell provides more warmth than a fleece. Consequently, it is less breathable. Being thicker, it also takes up more pack volume.
What makes a softshell special?
Several factors make a softshell stand out in terms of comfort and versatility:
- The fabric: lined with fleece on the inside and made from a water-repellent outer fabric.
- Versatility: a single jacket to protect against wind, cold, and light rain.
- Convenience: practical for skiing, cycling, or trail running in shoulder seasons.
Given the pros and cons of each, deciding between a fleece and a softshell is not always straightforward. To make the right choice, consider the following factors:
- The fit: these garments should sit as close to the body as possible to prevent heat from escaping.
- Pockets: strategically placed pockets help optimise ventilation and regulate core temperature.
- Drawcords: essential for easily adjusting the waist and cuffs.
- A hood: to keep your head at the same temperature level as the rest of your body.
Which to choose: fleece or softshell?
Choosing between a fleece and a softshell comes down to how you plan to use it. A fleece works best as a mid-layer, or as an outer layer on dry, windless days. A softshell jacket is better suited to changeable weather, when you need protection from wind and light rain. With its water-repellent, windproof fabric, a three-layer softshell offers better weather protection than a fleece. It is also useful if you do not have a separate outer layer. Its greater volume, however, may be a drawback. Check the forecast and the terrain you will be crossing to decide whether to wear a fleece or a softshell.
